Tomato Garden: The Heart of Vernon’s Pizza Scene

The Vibe: If there is one place that feels like the "town square" of Vernon pizza, it’s Tomato Garden. Located right on County Road 515, it’s the go-to for everyone from local families to hikers coming off the Appalachian Trail. The atmosphere is warm, no-frills, and consistently welcoming.

The Standout Pie: You have to try their Signature Tomato Basil Pizza. It’s famous for a reason—the crust is exceptionally light and airy (never "doughy"), and the fresh basil makes the flavors pop. If you're looking for something unique, their Cauliflower Crust with White Sauce is surprisingly crispy and a favorite for the gluten-free crowd.

Visitor Hack: They are used to the mountain rush. If you're staying at Mountain Creek, this is your most reliable "large order" spot.

Tomato Garden offers plenty of Vegetarian options!

Address: 530 Co Rd 515, Vernon Township, NJ 07462

Phone: (973) 764-4162

Hours: Wed - Sun 11am- 10pm, Tues & Wed CLOSED