Luca Trattoria: The Heart of the Village Slice

Credit: https://lucapizzawarwick.com/

The Vibe: Located in the Shoprite Plaza (South), Luca Trattoria is everything a hometown pizzeria should be. It’s family-owned, everything is made from scratch, and you’ll often see the owner, Peter, greeting regulars by name.

The Standout Pie: While their specialty pies are great, Luca’s is the place to get a Classic Large Cheese Pie. It’s the "Goldilocks" of pizza—not too greasy, perfect "foldable" crust, and a balanced sauce. If you want a square, their Sicilian is thick, airy, and consistently highly rated.

Visitor Hack: This is the best value in Warwick. If you have a big group to feed back at the hotel, Luca’s portions are generous and their prices are some of the fairest in the area.

Address: South Shoprite Plaza 153, NY-94, Warwick, NY 10990

Tel: (845) 986-2002

Hours: Mon - Sat 11am - 10pm, Sun 12pm - 9pm