Holland American Bakery: A 70-Year-Old Taste of the Netherlands
The Insider Tip: They have a 25¢ cup of coffee.
The Dutch Standard: Iconic Bakery
If you’re driving down Route 23 in Sussex and see a massive windmill, you haven't been transported to Europe—you’ve found Holland American Bakery. Since 1954, the Valkema family has been serving authentic Dutch treats that draw visitors from hours away. Stepping inside feels like walking into a 1950s Dutch shop, filled with Delft blue pottery, wooden shoes, and the smell of toasted cinnamon.
What to Order (The "Bakery Fix"):
The Famous Cinnamon Bread: This isn't just bread; it's practically a cake. It's dense, buttery, and packed with gooey cinnamon pockets. Locals stockpile loaves of this stuff—try it toasted with a thick pat of butter.
Speculaas (Windmill Cookies): These spicy, crunchy cinnamon cookies are the bakery’s signature. They are shaped like windmills and are the perfect companion to a cup of coffee.
Banket (Almond Ring): An almond-paste filled pastry that is flaky on the outside and rich on the inside. It’s a holiday staple, but locals buy it year-round.
Old-Fashioned Doughnuts: Their blueberry doughnuts actually have real blueberries in them—a rarity in the world of commercial baking.
The Insider Tip: They have a 25¢ cup of coffee. In 2026, finding anything for a quarter is a miracle. Grab a cup, a doughnut, and sit outside by the windmill to soak in the rural Sussex County vibes.
The "Dear Vernon" Visitor Hack: This is technically in Sussex/Wantage, just about 10 minutes from the Hamburg/Vernon line. It is closed on Sundays and Mondays, so plan your "souvenir" shopping for Tuesday through Saturday (6 AM – 6 PM).
The current owners are the 3rd generation of the same family!
The "Closed" Alert: They are closed on Mondays and Sundays so plan your trip accordingly!
Address: 246 Route 23, Sussex, NJ 07461
Tel: (973)875-5258
Hours: Tues -Sat 6:00am - 6:00pm, Sun & Mon CLOSED
